Garcia trade fallout
More thoughts on Wednesday's trade of Maikel Garcia, the departure of Kyle Isbel and a curious Royals Hall of Fame selection.
Wednesday was bonkers for Royals news. The day started, as you are all aware, with the news the Royals were shipping their starting third baseman, Maikel Garcia to the Seattle Mariners. Heading back to Kansas City was three pitchers.
Since the Royals 40-man roster was full at the time of the trade, and because they obtained three major leaguers while they sent only two (plus minor league reliever L.P. Langevin) to the Mariners, the Royals needed to open space on their roster. To accomplish that, the Royals designated center fielder Kyle Isbel for assignment.
The Royals then capped their day by announcing that Zack Greinke and Eric Hosmer were both elected to the team's Hall of Fame.
Busy, busy, busy.
I was planning on writing a more thorough breakdown on the pitchers—Bryce Miller, Logan Evans and Jose A. Ferrer—coming to Kansas City in the deal, but before we get to that in the coming days, I wanted to touch on the other two bits of news coming from One Royal Way, along with some other stray thoughts on the Garcia trade.

Let's start there. While Garcia was clearly the centerpiece of Wednesday's trade, I can't say I was surprised to see James McArthur included in the deal. He has over three years of service time and hasn't pitched in the majors due to injury since 2024. He's had a pair of procedures done to his elbow. The first surgery was to repair an olecranon fracture. The second was done almost a year later to address persistent soreness and inflammation. He was activated from the IL for the final day of the season, but didn't appear in the game.
There was hope at one time that McArthur could fill a higher-leverage role in the bullpen. It's possible he can work his way back, but he only made four appearances in the minors for the Royals last year. The Mariners are clearly fine with his medicals, but I wonder if that elbow is going to remain healthy.
The pitcher I was disappointed to see depart was L.P. Langevin. I am always loathe to scout the stats, but the dude struck out over 44 percent of batters he faced last year. Over 44 percent! He also walked over 16 percent of all batters. Langevin is a slinging right-hander who throws a fastball in the mid-90s and misses bats and the strike zone in equal measure. There's no way he can make it far with that kind of walk rate, but it would've be fun to continue to sweat those stat lines.
Having had about 24 hours to marinate on this trade, I still think the Royals got a bit of a light return, but not so egregious to make it a bad deal. Garcia will be missed, but, after missing the postseason the last two years, this roster needs a rethink.

Next, let's discuss the departure of Kyle Isbel.
Regular readers will know what I'm about to say: A team can carry Kyle Isbel if their lineup is solid one through eight. The Royals lineup is nowhere near that deep and Isbel's offensive output now cannot overcome the contributions he makes defensively.
In the end, it was a numbers game that caught up with Isbel. He has over five years of service time and was going to be eligible for arbitration for the third time. MLB Trade Rumors estimated he would earn $3.5 million next year. That's certainly not a fiscal anchor and Isbel can be depended upon posting around 1 fWAR or so there is value to be found, but again, the imbalance in his game makes that bad money. Isbel was a non-tender candidate, so the Royals just made the move a couple of day early.
I wrote in my look at free agent position players last week that the Royals needed to be looking for upgrades in left and center. My fear was that JJ Picollo would keep Isbel around for one more season. While it's never fun to see the team basically cut a player, it was the right move for the Royals. Removing Isbel from the roster doesn't change the calculus of the offseason. They still need to find a left fielder and a center fielder.
That means I don't think Carson Roccaforte is the answer. At least not to begin the season. I remain highly intrigued but he probably needs some more seasoning at Triple-A before finds himself in a big league dugout.

Finally, the Royals Hall of Fame elections. As noted at the top, the 2027 inductees will be Zack Greinke and Eric Hosmer. You know from my previous edition where I broke down the 12 candidates. Greinke was an automatic guy for me. So was Carlos Beltrán, who is apparently good enough for the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, but unworthy to be honor in left field at Kauffman Stadium. I appreciate the commitment to the bit.
Hosmer? If you were going to honor a player from those championship teams—that's not Alex Gordon since he's already in—why not pick the best guy? That would be Lorenzo Cain.
I keep telling myself it's just a team Hall of Fame. But if we can't get worked up about that, what really is there to stew over?
It was this part from the press release that absolutely floored me:
Greinke received 78.2% support and Hosmer received 80.2%.
Honestly, I appreciate this kind of bonkers from the electorate. If you're going to detach yourself from any kind of baseball reality, go full throttle.
I'm all for these team Halls of Fame being a big tent, but I also cannot get over the fact that there have been just nine players elected to the Royals Hall of Fame this century. It's good that there are two players going in next year. That's progress. I'd like to see some more guys going forward. I thought there were nine guys with solid cases this year. Hosmer was one of them, but I wouldn't have put him ahead of some of the others. Especially Beltrán and Billy Butler, who were both on the ballot for the final time. I suppose there's a veteran's committee to correct this oversight. Hey, Curt Nelson...Call me!
I've probably spent too much digital ink on this topic, but if you can't have a good baseball fit over something meaningless as a team hall of fame then I don't know what we're doing.
Comments ()